I read the book because I have heard about it, and a friend kindly loaned it to me, because I don't buy books that I don't intend to keep forever. It gets mentioned in many places and I do try to stay up-to-date with some of the pop-culture just so that I know what everybody is talking about. If you haven't heard, it is a self-help book that declares that "The Secret" is a law of attraction that successful people have known since ages and the author is bringing it to the commoners. And what is the big secret, this immutable law of the universe - Like attracts like. Hence you will get what you think about, because your thoughts will attract it to you. You have to think positive, think about what you want from life, and not what you don't want, and really believe that the universe is abundant enough to give you whatever it is that you want, and you will get it.
I am intrigued, amused, shocked and a little bit angered by the book. I buy the whole "think positive" idea. I completely agree that how your life, your day and your relationships turn out depends a little on luck and a lot on attitude. There is no denying it. But don't go using physics to explain this, especially if you have never studied physics in school, as the author claims, because it makes what you say ridiculous right there. The basic law of physics is that likes repel, not attract. Little kids do the experiment in preschool, with two magnets. If you are selling philosophy, just sell philosophy. Don't go bringing science into it.
Secondly, the book could have been named "Aham Brahma" (I am Brahma), the chant from Hindu scriptures. That is what the book is talking about. You should see yourself, and everything else in the universe, not as a physical entity, but a mass of energy (or spirit, or soul, or Brahma, or God for that matter, or whatever you want to name it) that is connected to the rest of the energy of the universe. Principal of conversation of energy says that the amount of energy in the universe never changes, it is only converted from one form to another, and The Bhagvad Gita states that "nobody ever dies". By controlling your energy, you in effect, control the universe. The Upanishad, ancient Hindu texts, say exactly that. The practices of various kinds of yoga are specifically designed to control the energy within you. It angers me that Hindu teachings are thus exploited, without giving credit where credit is due. The Hindu philosophy also states that once you connect with the "Brahma", that is you stop seeing yourself as a physical entity separate from the rest of the universe, you will attain great peace because you have freed yourself from material needs and desires. Nirvana! Hence, I find it immensely amusing that "The Secret" tells you to do all this so that you can have the fancy houses and cars that you always wanted! Yeah baby! Consume.....
Raising kids in a non-native environment while constantly worrying about striking the right balance.
3 comments:
That book sounds maddening!
Ever read the book "The Dilbert Principle"? If I remember right (I read it years ago) it starts off with the author of the Dilbert cartoon yakking about life in the office world. But then in the last chapters of the book it morphs into a discussion of how the author believes that you can get whatever you want from life by doing regular "affirmations," which is where you repeatedly repeat a short sentence about what it is that you want to happen. Scott Adams says that he's done this and that it has worked great for him.
I'm pretty skeptical of it all, but I was struck by the similarities between The Dilbert Principle and your review of "The Secret."
No I haven't read the Dilbert Principal. I find some of the Dilbert cartoons very funny and pointed, but others just plain boring. So I never felt like I wanted to read a whole book of that stuff.
It's interesting that you think that the book is ripping off Hindu principles - I felt the book was ripping off some of the basic tenets of Christianity.
Post a Comment